| # | Player | Pos | Team | Perf | CVI | Sentiment | Fan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Aaron Nola | SP | Phillies | C+ | F | F | — |
| 2 |  Blade Tidwell | SP | Giants | C+ | — | B+ | — |
| 3 |  Brandon Nimmo | LF |
Carson KellyC+
C
F
—
Every MLB player ranked by public sentiment, performance, contract value, and fan votes.
| # | Player | Pos | Team | Perf | CVI | Sentiment | Fan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Aaron Nola | SP | Phillies | C+ | F | F | — |
| 2 | Blade Tidwell | SP | Giants | C+ | — | B+ | — |
| 3 | Brandon Nimmo | LF |
| Rangers |
C+ |
D |
A+ |
— |
| 4 | Carson Kelly | C | Cubs | C+ | C | F | — |
| 5 |  Evan Carter | CF | Rangers | C+ | B+ | C- | — |
| 6 |  Francisco Alvarez | C | Mets | C+ | B | A | — |
| 7 |  Jalen Beeks | RP | Rangers | C+ | A | B | — |
| 8 |  Jeffrey Springs | SP | Athletics | C+ | C- | B- | — |
| 9 |  JT Brubaker | RP | Giants | C+ | B+ | B+ | — |
| 10 |  Kody Clemens | 2B | Twins | C+ | B- | F | — |
| 11 |  LaZaro Estrada | SP | Blue Jays | C+ | — | B+ | — |
| 12 |  MacKenzie Gore | SP | Rangers | C+ | C+ | B+ | — |
| 13 |  Marcell Ozuna | DH | Pirates | C+ | C- | F | — |
| 14 |  Miguel Rojas | 2B | Dodgers | C+ | C | B | — |
| 15 |  Rob Refsnyder | RF | Mariners | C+ | C | A+ | — |
| 16 |  Willy Adames | SS | Giants | C+ | F | C+ | — |
| 17 |  Xavier Edwards | SS | Marlins | C+ | A- | B+ | — |
| 18 |  Yoan Moncada | 3B | Angels | C+ | B- | B+ | — |
| 19 |  Agustin Ramirez | C | Marlins | C+ | B+ | B+ | — |
| 20 |  Ben Casparius | RP | Dodgers | C+ | B- | C | — |
| 21 |  Carlos Cortes | LF | Athletics | C+ | B- | C- | — |
| 22 |  Chad Patrick | SP | Brewers | C+ | C+ | B | — |
| 23 |  Chandler Simpson | CF | Rays | C+ | B- | B- | — |
| 24 |  CJ Kayfus | 1B | Guardians | C+ | B- | A | — |
| 25 |  Colt Keith | 2B | Tigers | C+ | C- | C- | — |
| 26 |  Denzel Clarke | CF | Athletics | C+ | B- | A | — |
| 27 |  Edgardo Henriquez | RP | Dodgers | C+ | B- | B+ | — |
| 28 |  Elvis Alvarado | RP | Athletics | C+ | B- | A+ | — |
| 29 |  Eric Orze | RP | Twins | C+ | C+ | C- | — |
| 30 |  Gabriel Moreno | C | Diamondbacks | C+ | B | F | — |
| 31 |  Gus Varland | RP | Nationals | C+ | B- | C | — |
| 32 |  Joel Payamps | RP | Braves | C+ | A- | B+ | — |
| 33 |  Jovani Moran | RP | Red Sox | C+ | A- | C- | — |
| 34 |  Juan Mejia | RP | Rockies | C+ | B- | B+ | — |
| 35 |  Juan Morillo | RP | Diamondbacks | C+ | C+ | B+ | — |
| 36 |  Justin Wrobleski | RP | Dodgers | C+ | B- | B+ | — |
| 37 |  Mason Fluharty | RP | Blue Jays | C+ | B | F | — |
| 38 |  Moises Ballesteros | C | Cubs | C+ | B- | A | — |
| 39 |  Nasim Nunez | SS | Nationals | C+ | B- | A | — |
| 40 |  Ryan Zeferjahn | RP | Angels | C+ | B | F | — |
| 41 |  Troy Johnston | OF | Rockies | C+ | C+ | B | — |
| 42 |  Tyler Tolbert | 2B | Royals | C+ | C+ | C- | — |
| 43 |  Will Warren | SP | Yankees | C+ | B- | B+ | — |
| 44 |  Xander Bogaerts | SS | Padres | C+ | F | B+ | — |
| 45 |  Zach McKinstry | 3B | Tigers | C+ | C+ | A | — |
| 46 |  Brady Singer | SP | Reds | C+ | C- | C+ | — |
| 47 |  Brayan Bello | SP | Red Sox | C+ | C- | F | — |
| 48 |  Brendan Donovan | 2B | Mariners | C+ | C+ | A+ | — |
| 49 |  Brent Headrick | RP | Yankees | C+ | A- | A | — |
| 50 |  Dustin Harris | LF | White Sox | C+ | — | C | — |