| # | Player | Pos | Team | Perf | CVI | Sentiment | Fan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Freddy Peralta | SP | Mets | B+ | B | D+ | — |
| 2 |  Justin Verlander | SP | Tigers | B+ | D+ | C- | — |
| 3 |  Yu Darvish | SP |
Andrew AbbottB+
A+
A
—
Every MLB player ranked by public sentiment, performance, contract value, and fan votes.
| # | Player | Pos | Team | Perf | CVI | Sentiment | Fan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Freddy Peralta | SP | Mets | B+ | B | D+ | — |
| 2 | Justin Verlander | SP | Tigers | B+ | D+ | C- | — |
| 3 | Yu Darvish | SP |
| Padres |
B+ |
D |
F |
— |
| 4 | Andrew Abbott | SP | Reds | B+ | A+ | A | — |
| 5 |  Cristian Javier | SP | Astros | B+ | C- | F | — |
| 6 |  Jesus Luzardo | SP | Phillies | B+ | C- | A | — |
| 7 |  Jose Urquidy | SP | Pirates | B+ | B+ | B+ | — |
| 8 |  Joe Ryan | SP | Twins | B+ | C+ | B- | — |
| 9 |  Kevin Gausman | SP | Blue Jays | B+ | F | A+ | — |
| 10 |  Hunter Barco | SP | Pirates | B+ | B+ | A+ | — |
| 11 |  Kris Bubic | SP | Royals | B+ | C | F | — |
| 12 |  Michael Wacha | SP | Royals | B+ | D | B- | — |
| 13 |  Zack Littell | SP | Nationals | B+ | C | C- | — |
| 14 |  Cody Ponce | SP | Blue Jays | B | C- | A | — |
| 15 |  Dylan Cease | SP | Blue Jays | B | F | A+ | — |
| 16 |  Kodai Senga | SP | Mets | B | D | A+ | — |
| 17 |  Luis Castillo | SP | Mariners | B | D- | B- | — |
| 18 |  Clay Holmes | SP | Mets | B | D+ | B- | — |
| 19 |  David Peterson | SP | Mets | B | C | C- | — |
| 20 |  Walker Buehler | SP | Padres | B | A- | F | — |
| 21 |  Yoshinobu Yamamoto | SP | Dodgers | B | D | A+ | — |
| 22 |  Yusei Kikuchi | SP | Angels | B | D- | F | — |
| 23 |  Chris Bassitt | SP | Orioles | B | D- | B+ | — |
| 24 |  Jack Flaherty | SP | Tigers | B | D | B- | — |
| 25 |  Jose Soriano | SP | Angels | B | B | A | — |
| 26 |  George Klassen | SP | Angels | B | — | B+ | — |
| 27 |  Michael King | SP | Padres | B | D- | D+ | — |
| 28 |  Ryne Nelson | SP | Diamondbacks | B | B | B+ | — |
| 29 |  Tanner Bibee | SP | Guardians | B | C- | F | — |
| 30 |  Luis Severino | SP | Athletics | B- | D- | B+ | — |
| 31 |  Robbie Ray | SP | Giants | B- | F | C- | — |
| 32 |  Edward Cabrera | SP | Cubs | B- | C+ | B+ | — |
| 33 |  Eric Lauer | SP | Blue Jays | B- | C+ | F | — |
| 34 |  Max Scherzer | SP | Blue Jays | B- | B- | A | — |
| 35 |  Sandy Alcantara | SP | Marlins | B- | D+ | A+ | — |
| 36 |  Adrian Houser | SP | Giants | B- | C- | A- | — |
| 37 |  Nick Pivetta | SP | Padres | B- | D+ | D+ | — |
| 38 |  Casey Mize | SP | Tigers | B- | C | C- | — |
| 39 |  Connelly Early | SP | Red Sox | B- | B- | B+ | — |
| 40 |  Emmet Sheehan | SP | Dodgers | B- | B- | B- | — |
| 41 |  Eury Perez | SP | Marlins | B- | B | A+ | — |
| 42 |  Michael Soroka | SP | Diamondbacks | B- | C | B+ | — |
| 43 |  Nolan McLean | SP | Mets | B- | B- | A+ | — |
| 44 |  Sean Burke | SP | White Sox | B- | B | C- | — |
| 45 |  Shota Imanaga | SP | Cubs | B- | D- | F | — |
| 46 |  Jeffrey Springs | SP | Athletics | B- | C- | B- | — |