Dustin May
#3 SP · Cardinals
Height
6'6"
Weight
180 lbs
Age
28
College
N/A
Draft
2016, Rd 3, #101
Experience
6 yrs
Bats/Throws
R/R
D+
C-
C
N/A
Fan VerdictWhat's your verdict?
Grade Dustin May
Your grade joins the crowd-sourced Fan Verdict.
The Verdict on Dustin, in One Read
On the field, Dustin May grades out as a middling SP for Cardinals (C- Performance). That places him 192nd of 252 graded starting pitchers. The contract is harder to defend: the Contract Value Index calls it a slight overpay (D+), with the cost outrunning the output. The public read is mixed (C Sentiment), drawn from current news and social signal rather than the box score.
Career StatsC-
| Year | Team | GP | ERA | W-L | K | WHIP | IP | SV |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Career |  | 83 | 3.9854949 | 22-26 | 357 | 1.2158704 | 0.0 | 0 |
| 2026 | | 12 | 4.59 | 3-6 | 60 | 1.29 | 66.2 | 0 |
| 2025 |
Current Contract
Length
1 year
Total Value
$12.5M
Guaranteed
$7.5M
AAV
$12.5M/yr
Guaranteed %60%
Performance Analysis
C-
FCA+
Dustin May's C- performance grade reflects the struggles of a middling starter who hasn't yet justified the Cardinals' $12.5M investment in his potential. The 28-year-old right-hander entered the season as an intriguing reclamation project, with the organization betting on his electric stuff despite a concerning injury history that has limited his availability over recent seasons. While his early-season competence has avoided disaster, May hasn't produced the dominant flashes that would validate St. Louis's faith in his franchise-caliber upside. As a 6-year veteran drafted in the third round back in 2016, May represents the classic high-ceiling, high-risk pitcher whose raw talent continues to tantalize evaluators even as consistency remains elusive. The Cardinals' measured optimism suggests they view this as a calculated gamble on unlocking his elite potential, but May needs to demonstrate both durability and sustained excellence to transform from an interesting project into a reliable rotation cornerstone.
Fan & Media Sentiment
C
Mixed
NegativeNeutralPositive
Dustin May's public perception sits at a cautious, tepid C — a narrative that accurately captures the tension between genuine upside and legitimate red flags in his first stretch with St. Louis. The media framing around the 28-year-old is defined by that exact contradiction: his best outing of the season against the Red Sox showcased the strikeout ability and frontline ceiling that made him an interesting acquisition, while his awful Cardinals debut triggered immediate skepticism about whether he could successfully make this transition at all. That sentiment grade essentially mirrors his on-field production, which is sitting at a C- — meaning the public isn't even giving him the benefit of the doubt he might otherwise earn; if anything, fans are grading his performance about as charitably as the results warrant. Mixed showings against Cleveland have only reinforced the inconsistency label, and in a market that has seen the Cardinals add rotation and bullpen depth through a flurry of roster moves — including waiver claims and trades involving several left-handed arms — any rotation spot that isn't pulling its weight draws heightened scrutiny. The Cardinals are 21-15 and holding the fifth seed in the National League Central, which means the stakes are real enough that a pitcher delivering C- output isn't invisible — he's a pressure point. The narrative trend is slowly ticking upward, but May hasn't done enough consistently to flip the conversation from "cautious optimism" to genuine confidence; right now he reads as a solid-starter talent stuck in a middling-performer story.
Contracts in the Same Value Band
Other same-position deals the Contract Value Index also places in the D band — a quick read on where Dustin's contract sits relative to comparable money.
How Dustin Compares at the Position
Dustin May ranks 192nd of 252 graded starting pitchers by performance. That slots Dustin between Zack Littell (C) just ahead and Yusei Kikuchi (C-) just behind.
Graded higher
Zack LittellNationalsCMitch KellerPiratesCKeider MonteroTigersCDustin MayC-
Graded lower
Yusei KikuchiAngelsRecent Games
| Date | OPP | Result | AB | H | R | HR | RBI | BB | SO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mon, 6/15 | vs SD | W 3-0 | - | - | - | 0 | - | - | - |
| Tue, 6/9 | @ NYM | W 7-0 | - | - | - | 0 | - | - | - |
News & Buzz
Live Discussion
Auto-moderated fan forum with 5-minute speaker turns
Discussion
Loading discussion...
Explore the leaderboards
About this player
Dustin May is a player in his 6th MLB season listed at SP for the Cardinals. FanVerdicts covers every MLB player, team, GM, and transaction — and puts your verdict on all of it. Sign in to cast your Fan Verdict on Dustin May, see where the crowd lands, and argue the call. FanVerdicts also brings its own read — performance, sentiment, and Contract Value Index — as one honest input alongside the crowd's. Where FanVerdicts has weighed in so far: Contract Value Index D+, Performance C-, Sentiment C.
The crowd's Fan Verdict moves in real time as fans vote on this profile. FanVerdicts' own read updates as new data lands — performance recalculates when MLB game stats post, sentiment shifts with media coverage and fan discussion, and the Contract Value Index recomputes when contract terms change. Contract details below show the structure (years, total value, average annual value, guarantees) behind the Contract Value Index read.
For league-wide context, the MLB hub has team rankings, GM report cards, the transactions feed, and live scoreboards. The MLB player rankings page sorts every active player by performance and contract value within their position.
