GM: Darren Mougey
Roster grades based on player performance, contract value, and fan sentiment.
103
Players
28
Transactions
99
Players Graded
*(53 active roster + 16 practice squad + IR/PUP/reserve lists)
Talk anything about the team
Loading…
Auto-moderated fan forum with 5-minute speaker turns
Loading discussion...
FanVerdicts covers the New York Jets the same way it covers every NFL franchise — every player, every contract, every move — and asks fans where the team really stands. Cast your Fan Verdict on the New York Jets, see where the crowd lands, and argue the call. FanVerdicts brings its own read too — performance, sentiment, and Contract Value Index — as one honest input alongside the crowd's. Where FanVerdicts has weighed in so far: Contract Value Index D+, Performance F, Sentiment F. Front office leadership: Darren Mougey.
FanVerdicts' Contract Value Index read reflects the value distribution across 99 of 103 active roster players carrying graded contracts — positive-value deals versus overpays. The performance read rolls up per-player on-field grades weighted by playing time, and the sentiment read reflects the recent transaction window (typically last 14 days), so it can shift quickly when a major signing or trade lands.
For league-wide context, the NFL hub has team rankings, GM report cards, draft simulations, and the transactions feed. The NFL team rankings page sorts every team by Contract Value Index, Performance, and Sentiment side-by-side.
Grade the New York Jets
Your grade joins the crowd-sourced Fan Verdict.
On the Contract Value Index, New York Jets is paying a slight premium relative to production (D+ Contract Value Index). That ranks 29th of 32 on Contract Value Index. The roster grades as a roster among the league’s thinnest (F Performance). The public read is sharply negative (F Sentiment), drawn from current news and social signal.
The New York Jets' contract portfolio earns a D+ Contract Value Index (CVI), reflecting a roster construction strategy that has left the front office with minimal margin for error heading into the 2026 offseason. Of the 26 graded contracts spanning the entire roster, only 7 represent genuine value acquisitions—a troubling 27% hit rate—while 8 deals classify as outright overpays, signaling systemic dysfunction in how management has allocated capital. Cornerback stands as the lone bright spot in the portfolio, a position group where the Jets have managed shrewd value, but that advantage is obliterated by the safety position, which ranks as the worst value cohort on the roster and represents dead money in a competitive AFC East. The grading scope covers 100% of the 26-man roster analyzed, offering complete visibility into the depth-chart spending patterns; what emerges is a franchise caught between competing philosophies—neither fully committed to cost-efficient depth nor to premium star power—leaving the organization handcuffed. With the Jets sitting at 3-14 and locked out of playoff contention, this contract structure compounds the on-field crisis: bad deals cannot be easily shed, young talent may not develop within the current cap constraints, and the front office lacks the financial flexibility to pivot toward either a rebuild or a win-now retooling. Until new leadership implements discipline in contract negotiations and avoids the sunk-cost trap of defending past mistakes, the Jets will remain trapped in a middle zone where they cannot afford to lose and cannot afford to build.
New York Jets ranks 29th of 32 graded teams by Contract Value Index. That slots them between the Carolina Panthers (C) just ahead and the Arizona Cardinals (D+) just behind.
Graded higher
Carolina PanthersCTampa Bay BuccaneersC-Washington CommandersD+Graded lower
Arizona CardinalsD+The New York Jets roster is bottom-feeder caliber, with a performance grade of F reflecting fundamental roster construction failures across the board. With only 2 starters graded among 26 total players on the roster, this is a dangerously top-heavy setup that leaves zero margin for injury or inconsistency—the remaining 24 players consist of 9 rotation contributors and 11 depth pieces, meaning the team has no reliable safety net and is entirely dependent on those two reliable players to carry the load. Linebacker is the lone bright spot, the one position group that grades out as a genuine strength, but that single competent unit cannot mask the catastrophic weakness at quarterback, where the Jets lack a franchise-caliber QB capable of elevating the offense or managing games at a professional level. With neither offense nor defense graded favorably (both tiers are unprovided in the data, indicating neither side is strong enough to earn designation), this is a roster devoid of identity and lacking any operational foundation—you cannot build a winning team on two capable starters and hope the rest figure it out. The 3-14 record and five-game losing streak say what the grades already confirm: this roster is in freefall and will require wholesale reconstruction, not marginal upgrades. Until the Jets address the quarterback void and meaningfully upgrade rotation depth across both lines, they will remain uncompetitive regardless of coaching changes or mid-season adjustments.
The New York Jets' offseason has been an unmitigated disaster in the eyes of their fanbase and media observers, earning an F sentiment grade that reflects widespread frustration and loss of confidence in front office direction. Of 32 total transactions evaluated, only 7 drew positive reactions from fans and analysts, while 13 moves faced outright criticism and 12 landed in mixed-to-skeptical territory—a 2:1 ratio of negative-to-positive that signals deep organizational dysfunction. The best-received move, David Bailey, barely registers above replacement-level value (C-), which tells you everything about how thin the optimism is; the worst move, Lenny Krieg, earned an F grade and became a lightning rod for the fanbase's contempt. With a 3-14 record already in the books and the team positioned dead last in the AFC East, there's no goodwill buffer—fans are interpreting every transaction through the lens of a catastrophic 2025 season and viewing the 2026 offseason as another incompetent swing-and-miss rather than a genuine reset. The pattern is unmistakable: this front office is not rebuilding with credibility or long-term vision, but rather lurching from one failed experiment to the next, and the Jets' own supporters have checked out. Expect continued pressure on decision-makers heading into the regular season; patience is exhausted, and no single transaction is going to restore faith in the current regime.
Peers ranked by Contract Value Index grade among players at the same position. Tap any name for their full profile.