| # | Player | Pos | Team | Sentiment | CVI | Perf▼ | Fan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Jessie Bates III | S | Atlanta Falcons | B- | B | A | N/A |
| 2 |  Xavier Watts | S | Atlanta Falcons | B- | A+ | A | N/A |
| 3 |  Jalen Pitre | S | Houston Texans | B- | B- | A | N/A |
| 4 |  Talanoa Hufanga | S | Denver Broncos | B- | B- | A- | N/A |
| 5 |  Cam Bynum | S | Indianapolis Colts | B | C+ | A- | N/A |
| 6 |  Antoine Winfield Jr. | S | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | B+ | C | A- | N/A |
| 7 |  C.j. Gardner-johnson | S | Buffalo Bills | B- | B+ | A- | N/A |
| 8 | Chauncey Gardner-Johnson | S | Buffalo Bills | B- | B+ | A- | N/A |
| 9 |  Amani Hooker | S | Tennessee Titans | B- | B- | B+ | N/A |
| 10 |  Jalen Thompson | S | Dallas Cowboys | B- | C+ | B+ | N/A |
| 11 |  Reed Blankenship | S | Houston Texans | B | B- | B+ | N/A |
| 12 |  Nick Emmanwori | S | Seattle Seahawks | B | B+ | B+ | N/A |
| 13 |  Jordan Poyer | S | Free Agent | B | A | B+ | N/A |
| 14 |  Tykee Smith | S | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | B- | A- | B+ | N/A |
| 15 |  Geno Stone | S | Buffalo Bills | B- | A- | B+ | N/A |
| 16 |  Quentin Lake | S | Los Angeles Rams | B | C | B+ | N/A |
| 17 |  Alohi Gilman | S | Kansas City Chiefs | B | B- | B | N/A |
| 18 |  Jordan Battle | S | Cincinnati Bengals | B | B+ | B | N/A |
| 19 |  Coby Bryant | S | Chicago Bears | B | C- | B | N/A |
| 20 |  Justin Reid | S | New Orleans Saints | B | C | B | N/A |
| 21 |  Kyle Dugger | S | Cincinnati Bengals | B- | B+ | B | N/A |
| 22 |  Antonio Johnson | S | Jacksonville Jaguars | B- | B | B | N/A |
| 23 |  Tre'von Moehrig | S | Carolina Panthers | B+ | C- | B | N/A |
| 24 |  Tony Jefferson | S | Los Angeles Chargers | B- | B | B | N/A |
| 25 |  Joshua Metellus | S | Minnesota Vikings | B- | C | B | N/A |
| 26 |  Evan Williams | S | Green Bay Packers | B | B | B- | N/A |
| 27 |  Nick Cross | S | Washington Commanders | B- | C | B- | N/A |
| 28 |  Grant Delpit | S | Cleveland Browns | B | C- | B- | N/A |
| 29 |  Chuck Clark | S | Detroit Lions | B- | B- | B- | N/A |
| 30 |  Cole Bishop | S | Buffalo Bills | B- | B- | B- | N/A |
| 31 |  Jevon Holland | S | New York Giants | B | D+ | B- | N/A |
| 32 |  Dadrion Taylor-demerson | S | Arizona Cardinals | B- | B | B- | N/A |
| 33 |  Ronnie Hickman | S | Cleveland Browns | B+ | C | B- | N/A |
| 34 |  Jonas Sanker | S | New Orleans Saints | B- | B- | B- | N/A |
| 35 |  Jaylinn Hawkins | S | Baltimore Ravens | B+ | C- | C+ | C+ |
| 36 |  Jaylinn Hawkins | S | Baltimore Ravens | B+ | C- | C+ | N/A |
| 37 |  Malik Mustapha | S | San Francisco 49ers | B- | B- | C+ | N/A |
| 38 |  Ji'ayir Brown | S | San Francisco 49ers | B | B- | C+ | N/A |
| 39 |  Malaki Starks | S | Baltimore Ravens | B- | C | C+ | N/A |
| 40 |  Damar Hamlin | S | Buffalo Bills | B | C | C+ | N/A |
| 41 |  Malachi Moore | S | New York Jets | B | B- | C+ | N/A |
| 42 |  Marcus Epps | S | Philadelphia Eagles | B- | C | C+ | N/A |
| 43 |  Jaylen Mccollough | S | Los Angeles Rams | B- | C+ | C | N/A |
| 44 |  Craig Woodson | S | New England Patriots | B | C | C | N/A |
| 45 |  P.j. Locke | S | Dallas Cowboys | B- | D+ | C | N/A |
| 46 |  Chamarri Conner | S | Kansas City Chiefs | B- | C+ | C | N/A |
| 47 |  Javon Bullard | S | Green Bay Packers | B- | C | C | N/A |
| 48 |  Maxen Hook | S | Seattle Seahawks | B- | C+ | C | N/A |
| 49 |  Kahlef Hailassie | S | Minnesota Vikings | B | C+ | C- | N/A |
| 50 |  Lonnie Johnson Jr. | S | Miami Dolphins | B- | C- | C- | N/A |
| 51 |  Kevin Winston Jr. | S | Tennessee Titans | B- | C- | C- | N/A |
| 52 |  George Odum | S | Indianapolis Colts | B- | D+ | C- | N/A |
| 53 |  Sydney Brown | S | Atlanta Falcons | B+ | D+ | D+ | N/A |
| 54 |  Miles Killebrew | S | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | B- | D | D | N/A |
| 55 |  Lathan Ransom | S | Carolina Panthers | B | D+ | D | N/A |
| 56 |  Terrell Burgess | S | New Orleans Saints | B+ | D+ | D | N/A |
| 57 |  Alijah Clark | S | Dallas Cowboys | B- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 58 |  Dell Pettus | S | New England Patriots | B | D | D | N/A |
| 59 |  Kendell Brooks | S | Tennessee Titans | B- | D+ | D | N/A |
| 60 |  J.t. Gray | S | Philadelphia Eagles | B- | D | D- | N/A |
| 61 |  Keondre Jackson | S | Baltimore Ravens | B | D | D- | N/A |
| 62 |  Dean Clark | S | New York Jets | B+ | D | D- | N/A |
| 63 |  Jl Skinner | S | Denver Broncos | B | D- | D- | N/A |
| 64 |  Jessie Bates | S | Detroit Lions | B- | F | F | N/A |
| 65 | Aholi Gilman | S | Kansas City Chiefs | B | C+ | — | N/A |
| 66 |  Genesis Smith | S | Los Angeles Chargers | B- | C+ | N/A | N/A |
| 67 |  Jalon Kilgore | S | Buffalo Bills | B- | C+ | N/A | N/A |
| 68 |  Lorenzo Styles Jr | S | New Orleans Saints | B- | C+ | N/A | N/A |
| 69 |  Zakee Wheatley | S | Carolina Panthers | B- | C+ | N/A | N/A |