TIM Settle

Career StatsC+

Year	Team	GP	Sacks	Tkl	TFL
Career		124	15.0	130	23
2025		12	1.0	15	3.5
2024		17	5.0	31	7.5
2023		17	1.0

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

At $7.83M AAV on a three-year deal, Tim Settle earns a B- Contract Value Index (CVI) — a verdict that reflects reasonable but not exceptional efficiency for an established interior defensive lineman entering his age-28 season. The $25M commitment from Washington signals genuine organizational belief in Settle's ability to anchor the defensive line, and the media framing around this reunion leans decidedly positive, with multiple outlets highlighting his "destructive" potential and the significance of bringing back a familiar face. For a fifth-round pick out of 2018 who has carved out a legitimate NFL career, Settle represents the kind of dependable rotational presence that earns a steady roster spot, and at this price point he sits in a reasonable range for a solid starter at his position — not a bargain, but not an overpay either. The CVI stops short of a higher mark primarily because the contract asks him to be more than a complementary piece over three years, which introduces some term risk if his role remains rotational rather than every-down. That said, the homecoming narrative is genuine, and if Settle delivers the steady run defense and occasional pass rush upside the fanbase is expecting, Washington will be comfortable with this investment heading into a regular season still 140 days away. The three-year length is the one area to watch — by year three, Settle will be 30, and any regression in quickness or pass-rush productivity could make the back end of this deal a modest cap inefficiency.

Contracts in the Same Value Band

Other same-position deals the Contract Value Index also places in the B band — a quick read on where TIM's contract sits relative to comparable money.

Performance Analysis

Tim Settle's tape and counting stats together earn a C+ performance grade. The 28-year-old defensive tackle logged 15 tackles and 1 sack across 12 games in the 2025 season, a modest output that slots him squarely in the rotational starter tier rather than an interior defensive anchor. His tackle volume represents his most reliable contribution, but the sack total underscores a persistent gap in consistent interior pressure — a critical limitation for a defensive lineman tasked with collapsing the pocket. Settle's durability was respectable, appearing in 12 games, though that production level and the injury profile implicit in an "every-down starter" discussion suggest he remains best suited for depth rotations rather than heavy snap-load roles. The media framing positioning him as a "familiar face with modest upside" and a "solid rotational starter" aligns with this grade: he's a useful complementary piece on the Commanders' defensive line, not a transformative force. His stated motivation to be "destructive" reflects veteran self-awareness, but the gap between intention and on-field execution — evidenced by the tackle-to-sack ratio — is exactly what keeps him in the C+ band rather than climbing into above-average territory.

How TIM Compares at the Position

TIM Settle ranks 77th of 216 graded defensive tackles by performance. That slots TIM between Bill Norton (C+) just ahead and Tim Settle Jr. (C+) just behind.

Current Sentiment

The Washington Commanders' reunion with Tim Settle has generated cautiously optimistic reactions across the fanbase and media, earning a **B-** sentiment grade from analysts. Multiple outlets have framed this three-year, $25.5M deal as a smart "homecoming" move that prioritizes roster continuity over flashy signings, with fans expressing genuine excitement about bringing back a popular locker room presence. The media narrative consistently positions Settle as a solid rotational starter rather than a defensive anchor, which has tempered expectations while maintaining positive sentiment around the familiarity factor. Skeptical voices have questioned whether Settle has truly developed into an every-down starter since his departure, but the modest contract structure has largely silenced concerns about overpaying for nostalgia. Overall, this signing is being perceived as a low-risk, moderate-reward move that addresses depth needs without breaking the bank or dramatically shifting championship expectations.