Colton Mckivitz

Current Contract

Contract Value Index (CVI)

Spotrac flags Colton McKivitz's contract as a market-rate deal; FanVerdicts grades it C+ Contract Value Index because the production-to-pay ratio shakes out accordingly. McKivitz carried a modest workload in the 2025 season—3 tackles across 17 games—which underscores his role as a positional anchor rather than a high-impact edge-setter, a gap the C+ CVI reflects in its assessment of a $15M AAV commitment over three years. The right tackle market rewards stability and scheme fit over splash plays, and at 29 years old in his sixth professional season, McKivitz delivers exactly that: he's a solid starter whose reliable, low-drama tenure has earned organizational trust, evidenced by the 49ers' willingness to extend him despite opportunities to test free agency elsewhere. The sentiment around him remains firmly in the A- range—media framing emphasizes his standing as a cornerstone of San Francisco's offensive infrastructure and his inclusion in recent top-100 player rankings—yet the steady F performance grade and pedestrian tackle totals reveal the contract is priced for a dependable journeyman, not a premium talent commanding top-five positional money. With three years of runway at his current AAV, McKivitz represents a manageable financial commitment aligned with his ceiling: a professional, injury-resistant starter who won't break the bank but also won't elevate the offense through elite play. The CVI grade acknowledges that trade-off fairly—he's getting paid like a quality backup-to-starter hybrid at a premium position, which is neither a steal nor an overpay in an offseason landscape where the 49ers are clearly prioritizing continuity up front.

Contracts in the Same Value Band

Other same-position deals the Contract Value Index also places in the C band — a quick read on where Colton's contract sits relative to comparable money.

Performance Analysis

Snap share and per-play impact line up to a B+ performance grade for Colton McKivitz. The sixth-year veteran right tackle has solidified himself as a reliable above-average starter in San Francisco's offensive infrastructure, demonstrating the kind of consistent, technically sound play that defines a dependable anchor at the position—not flashy enough to crack Pro Bowl conversations, but precisely the type of performer who allows a contending team to focus its resources elsewhere. His 2025 season durability stands out: 17 games played signals McKivitz has proven himself durable and available, a baseline expectation for offensive linemen that he has clearly met. The performance grade reflects solid execution in pass protection and run-blocking mechanics rather than dominant statistical standouts—tackle counts (3 in 2025) are naturally depressed for offensive linemen and offer little diagnostic value, but his snap consistency and scheme fit are the real metrics driving the evaluation. McKivitz's media narrative is anchored in organizational trust: the 49ers' three-year, $45M extension represents a clear institutional bet that the right tackle position is settled, and his inclusion in PFF's top 101 players of 2025 validates that "solved problem" framing heading into 2026. For a fifth-round pick from 2020, this career arc—steady employment, contract security, and quiet leadership standing—is the ceiling most linemen aspire to reach.

How Colton Compares at the Position

Colton Mckivitz ranks 1st of 189 graded offensive tackles by performance. Colton grades out ahead of names like Jc Latham (B).

Peers ranked by Performance grade among players at the same position. Tap any name for their full profile.

Current Sentiment

Colton McKivitz has built genuinely positive public standing entering the 2026 season, earning an A- sentiment grade that reflects a media narrative defined more by organizational trust than individual star power. The driving force behind that narrative is the 49ers' three-year, $45M extension — a clear institutional endorsement that beat writers have framed as the team treating the right tackle position as a solved problem rather than an ongoing concern, and his inclusion among PFF's top 101 players in 2025 reinforces that "solid starter" classification in the broader football conversation. What makes this A- particularly interesting is that it exists in sharp contrast to a steady F performance grade — McKivitz's public perception is being carried almost entirely by the organizational commitment and the quiet-competence reputation offensive linemen cultivate over time, not by on-field dominance that moves highlight packages. The recent signing of Trent Williams adds a notable wrinkle to the perception picture: bringing in a player of that caliber signals the 49ers are fortifying the line, which could either elevate McKivitz's standing as part of a formidable unit or gradually shift media focus away from him as a headliner in offensive line coverage. Ultimately, McKivitz sits in that comfortable media space where the absence of bad news is itself good news — no injury drama, no performance controversies, no contract holdout storylines — and for a six-year veteran who came in as a fifth-round pick in 2020, that kind of sustained organizational confidence is the narrative foundation most linemen never get to stand on.