Simeon Woods Richardson

Performance Analysis

Among starting pitchers on the Blue Jays, Simeon Woods Richardson's output grades to a D+ performance level. The 25-year-old right-hander struck out 26 batters across 12 games in 2026, his lone bright spot in an otherwise troubling season marked by early exits and an inability to provide reliable innings depth. His strikeout rate is the closest thing to a functional foundation here, but it's been drowned out by a complete absence of wins and a pattern of getting chased from games early — the kind of inefficiency that transforms raw stuff into liability rather than asset. With 12 appearances already behind him, Woods Richardson is getting opportunities to prove himself, yet the results keep pointing the same direction: a pitcher still searching for consistency at the major-league level. The media narrative that preceded his trade to Toronto centered on a mechanical overhaul — specifically a sharper split-finger pitch — as the developmental pathway forward, but his on-field results have failed to validate that optimism, widening the gap between what his arsenal *should* do and what it's actually producing in games. The Blue Jays' recent flurry of starting-pitcher signings signals organizational impatience; Richardson is now operating within genuine rotation competition, and unless he strings together quality starts immediately, he risks becoming a depth casualty in a organization actively upgrading its pitching inventory.