Javier Baez

Contract Value Index (CVI)

The Tigers' decision to commit $140M over six years to Javier Báez represents one of the most questionable allocation of resources in recent MLB memory, earning a D- CVI that reflects both poor timing and inflated compensation. At $23.3M annually, Detroit is paying Báez like an elite middle infielder when his production has consistently hovered in serviceable starter territory — the kind of player typically valued around $12-15M in today's market. The contract becomes even more problematic when considering Báez's age curve and the Tigers' competitive timeline; they're paying premium dollars during what should be his decline phase while their window remains several years away. Center field presents additional complications, as Báez's defensive metrics suggest he's better suited for second base or shortstop, meaning Detroit is potentially misallocating talent while overpaying for positional flexibility. With a farm system that ranks among the league's most promising, the Tigers had every incentive to develop internal options rather than committing this level of financial resources to a player whose ceiling appears to be solid contributor rather than difference-maker. This deal handcuffs Detroit's payroll flexibility precisely when they should be preparing to supplement their emerging core with impact talent, making it a textbook example of poor roster construction timing.

Performance Analysis