Giancarlo Stanton's 13-year, $25M AAV contract earns a D CVI — a deal that looked questionable from the start and has only gotten worse as injuries have limited his availability despite elite production when healthy. The 36-year-old designated hitter remains a legitimate offensive force with an A performance grade, showcasing the elite power that made him the 2017 MVP and recent ALCS MVP, but his massive salary becomes increasingly difficult to justify given his inability to stay on the field consistently. At $25 million annually for a player entering his late thirties, the Yankees are paying premium money for what has become part-time production, creating a significant roster construction challenge. The media's cautiously optimistic framing around Stanton reflects the perpetual hope that this will be the year he finally stays healthy, but years of missed games have conditioned even the most optimistic observers to expect disappointment despite his undeniable talent when available. His partnership with Aaron Judge creates genuine excitement and historic home run milestones, yet the contract's length and dollar commitment make every injury absence feel like a franchise-crippling loss. The Yankees are essentially paying superstar money for a player whose career stage and injury history suggest diminishing returns, making this one of baseball's most problematic long-term deals.
Performance Analysis
A
FCA+
Recent Games
Date
OPP
Result
AB
H
R
HR
RBI
BB
SO
Fri, 4/10
@ TB
L 3-5
3
1
1
0
0
1
1
Sun, 4/5
vs MIA
L 6-7
5
2
0
0
0
0
2
News & Buzz
Live Discussion
Auto-moderated fan forum with 5-minute speaker turns
Giancarlo Stanton grades as an elite performer among MLB designated hitters, earning a A Performance grade. He is hitting with a 0.258 batting average and a 0.873 OPS (above the league average of .720, an above-average mark) this season. With 453 home runs and 1170 RBI through 1728 games (a 42-HR, 110-RBI pace over a full season), he brings elite power production to the lineup. His 42 stolen bases add an elite speed dimension that creates additional offensive value. As a aging veteran at 36, Giancarlo is a key contributor for the Yankees. A 1728-game sample provides high confidence in this grade.
Fan & Media Sentiment
B+
Positive
NegativeNeutralPositive
The baseball world views Giancarlo Stanton through a lens of cautious optimism, with fans and media torn between his undeniable talent and his frustrating inability to stay healthy. His partnership with Aaron Judge creates genuine excitement when both sluggers are clicking, as their combined power represents one of the most feared duos in baseball, but Stanton's $25M annual salary becomes a lightning rod whenever he hits the injured list. The media narrative consistently follows this pattern: spring training health reports generate hope, strong performance early in seasons builds momentum, then inevitable injury concerns resurface to dampen enthusiasm. His actual elite-level production when healthy creates a fascinating disconnect — Stanton remains a legitimate middle-of-the-order threat who can carry an offense, yet public perception stays guarded because availability trumps ability in today's game. The 2026 season looms as a potential turning point where sustained health could finally align his reputation with his performance, but until then, Stanton remains baseball's most talented "what if" story. Yankees fans want to believe, but years of missed games have conditioned them to expect disappointment despite flashes of his former MVP brilliance.
